Being rated is a strange feeling. We spend our working week writing and enforcing rules for other people's trading, and then a website comes along and grades ours. TradingIsAJob, which rates 65 prop firms, gave us 75 out of 100 on its card, last checked on 13 November 2026. In most schools that's a solid B with a note home that says "good work, show more of it", which is roughly what the card says. We'll start with the scores, since that's probably why you clicked, and then I'll tell you about the part no rating can score: what this job really takes, as we see it on our own trading floor.
The site starts every review with one question: after you pass, whose money do you trade? A firm that keeps you on a simulated account after a pass goes into one group, and a firm that puts you on a live account with its own capital goes into another. It puts the difference bluntly. On a simulated account you're trading against the firm. On a real account with real money, your profit is the firm's profit.
Only then does it score. It looks at whose money you trade, how much you can really lose in a day, whether the work can become a career, whether the firm pays, and whether the price and the rules are fair. Anything it can't verify counts as average, so a firm that publishes less gets no benefit of the doubt. Every criterion is written out in the TradingIsAJob methodology.
The card puts us among the real prop firms where you pay for an evaluation first, and it adds "allocation at the firm's discretion". We'll come back to that. It could verify most of what it checked about us, which mostly tells you that we publish a lot.
The top group in the rating is US trading companies that put their own capital behind their traders. You don't pay to join them, and most of them only take people who live in the US. For traders outside the US, the rating lists three real prop firms that take traders remotely. In all three you pay for an evaluation, and a pass leads to a live account. On the rating as we read it on 17 November 2026, the site ranks us number one of those three, with the 75 from our card. The next firm is three points behind us, which is close enough that nobody here is printing T-shirts.
Our best mark is for real risk: 90. The card calls ours the "best-designed risk rules in our rating": we limit how much a trader can lose in a day, a week and a month. We wrote those rules to be annoying, so it's nice that someone noticed.
Then comes the low mark. "Do they pay" gets 43. We've read that number several times, hoping it would turn into a 75, and it hasn't. The card gives two reasons.
The first is that there's no public record of profit shares paid out. That one is fair. We haven't published one, and the mark will stay where it is until we do. Internally, though, in the last four years I have personally approved and transferred more than $20 million in profit shares to our traders. I know a sentence in a blog post isn't a public record, which is why the 43 stays for now.
The second is that, as the card reads our terms, a pass gives no right to capital. Our position is different, and we're bringing all our documents in line with it:
A confirmed pass opens your level, subject to review and identity checks.
The full assessment, with its strengths and its "watch out for" list, is on hi2morrow's TradingIsAJob rating card. We read the "watch out for" list first, like everybody does.
Prop Firm Pal has a verified page for us. It lists our qualification tiers and prices, the countries we don't accept and our main rules, all taken from our site on 20 October. It has zero reviews so far, which is the only perfect record in this article. Its comparison box lines us up against firms that give traders a bigger share than we do, and we lose that row every time. We're keeping ours. It's the trader's share of what they make with the firm's own money on a real account, and the box has no row for that.
Forex Peace Army has a page for us as well. Its title asks the question every new firm gets, "legit or scam?", and then, with zero reviews, it politely declines to answer. It also lists our founding date as unknown. Prop Firm Pal says 2023. That's right for hi2morrow, although the desk behind it has been trading for more than 15 years. Either way, we exist: we checked this morning.
Most firms on these sites trade forex, futures or CFDs on simulated accounts, so the comparison boxes ask about drawdowns, splits and how fast you get paid. Those numbers help, but the rating's first question helps more, and you can ask it of any firm, ours included.
There is a lot of training behind this firm, so I want to tell you about it.
What follows is how we train the people on our own trading floor. It isn't a course that comes with the qualification. It's what I'd want anyone to know before they decide to trade for a living, with us or with anyone else.
We've run a trading desk for more than 15 years. It has always been a physical desk, so it was limited by its location and by how many people we could seat and train. Hiring was always internal. Our active traders referred people who were interested, we gathered them in groups of 20 to 30 and ran group sessions, and usually a handful from each group got a seat.
Our group now works across several countries. So far we've onboarded more than 300 people onto the desk, and they differ in almost every way: background, age, what they did before. Most of them didn't make it, because they quit or because we let them go. The team that remains is just as mixed. Some joined us straight after high school. Some gave up serious careers to trade, some of them after ten years. Some started part-time.
hi2morrow is our new way of hiring. It's open to people we would never have met through a referral.
Later articles will tell these stories one trader at a time: each case, and what their days look like.
Remember the rating's first question: whose money do you trade? On our floor the traders trade the group's own capital. That changes how you train people. When the money is real, a newcomer's mistakes cost the firm, and the illusions they bring with them get expensive fast. So the training starts with the picture in the newcomer's head, before any chart or setup.
What the people on our floor all share is the reason they came. They want the freedom trading offers: no boss standing over them, their own hours, their own decisions, a result that belongs to them. I understand that. It's a real thing to want. The trouble is the picture most people carry of it.
You've seen the films. A trader in a good suit, a supercar outside the office, supermodels at the party, a yacht, a trip around the world, a hotel suite, dinner at the table next to a celebrity. Trading looks like the short road to all of it.
The films are true in a sense, but not completely. They show the end of a story and skip almost everything that came before it, and what came before is the part that matters.
Most people are wishful thinkers, and they don't want to tell a plan apart from a wish, because a wish is more pleasant. A plan has steps, a cost and a day when you check whether it's working. A wish has only the ending. When someone arrives on a trading floor with a wish, the first losing week feels like an injustice and the first winning day feels like proof. Both feelings are wrong, and both lead to bad decisions.
Everybody wants to be rich quick. Nobody wants to put in the effort, or face the difficulties that come with it. I'm not complaining about people when I say that. Most of us are built that way, which is why the illusion is so hard to give up. What the films really sell is the idea that the effort can be skipped.
I'm describing the films so you can recognise the picture, and I'm not holding it up as a goal. Nothing in this article, and nothing about our qualification, is a promise of that life.
In our office, the first thing we did, management and the training staff together, was to break the newcomers' illusion about this field. Before anything else, a newcomer hears what the job really is.
Trading is a full-time job, like any other job. It has hours. It has a risk desk that checks your work. It has rules you didn't write and can't change. It has bad days you still have to show up for, and good days you can't let go to your head. If you manage to master its rules, then, and only then, can you start to reach the freedom people come to trading for. It comes after the work, never instead of it, and nobody can promise it to you. We can't either.
We have a saying among traders: "Trading is the hardest way to the easiest money." From outside, the money looks easy: a few clicks, a few minutes, a number that goes up. Nobody outside sees the road to those few minutes, and that road is the hardest one I know.
You'll have to work hard, ten hours a day, every day, for months. Ten hours sounds like a lot until you notice that the US market is only open for six and a half of them. The rest goes on preparing for the open and going back over what went wrong. It usually takes 8 to 12 months to understand the rules, test them, and get comfortable with every part of this job. Every part covers more than people expect.
You have to get comfortable with losing money. You will lose it, often, and you have to learn to treat a loss as part of the work. A loss you took by your rules is a cost. A loss you took by breaking them is a lesson you paid for, and learning to tell the two apart, quickly and honestly, takes longer than learning any setup.
You have to get comfortable with making money, too, and that one surprises people. A good day can do as much damage as a bad one if it changes how you trade the next morning. Feeling clever after a big day is the quickest way I know to size up too far.
You'll make mistakes, and the work is in understanding each one: what you did, why you did it, which rule it broke and what you'll do differently next time. A mistake you understand makes you better. One you explain away tends to come back.
And you're constantly under pressure, from every side. The market moves whether or not you're ready. Your mentor pushes you on the trades you'd rather forget. Your risk manager watches what you do and steps in. All of it at once, every day, and all the while you have to keep your head cool.
That pressure comes from people who are on your side, and it's meant to be uncomfortable. A mistake someone points out on Tuesday costs less than the same mistake you find on your own a month later.
A job isn't judged on one morning. The judgement comes from months of work, and a live account with us is judged the same way. Our limits are set so that one bad day, one bad week or even one bad month can't cost you your level. Moving up has no deadline. It happens when the results are there, and not before.
A day that goes well proves very little, and so does a day that goes badly. What counts is what you do across hundreds of them. That's also why the 8 to 12 months matter. They aren't a waiting period. It takes that long for enough days to pile up that you and the people around you can see what kind of trader you are.
Nobody warns you how much of this job is about feelings. You can learn a setup in a week. Learning to take it while your heart is pounding takes much longer, and that's the hard part.
Fear usually comes first, after the first real loss. A loss hurts more than a win of the same size feels good. People are built that way, and it makes newcomers do odd things: they close winners early to lock in the good feeling, and hold losers too long so they don't have to feel the bad one. You'll feel it anyway. What helps is deciding what you'll do before the trade, so the feeling has nothing left to decide.
Then there's the win that goes to your head. After a run of good days you feel like you've cracked it. You size up, you loosen your rules a little, you take the trade you'd normally skip. From the inside, euphoria feels exactly like confidence, and that's what makes it dangerous.
Revenge trading is the one everybody has heard of and almost everybody does at least once. You lose, you're angry, and the next trade isn't about the market anymore. It's about getting the money back, as if the market owed you something. It doesn't.
Boredom gets less attention than it deserves. Most of a trading day is waiting. The films leave that out, because on camera it's someone staring at a screen, which is exactly what it is. Bored traders take trades to feel something, and those trades tend to cost more than the interesting ones.
And then there's doubt. After a few losses, doing nothing starts to feel like the safe choice, so you skip the trade your plan told you to take. It works without you, of course. The trade you skipped always works, or at least that's how it feels, and from there it's a short step to chasing the next one too late.
One thing helps more than people expect: naming the feeling exactly, out loud or on paper. "I'm angry and I want it back" is a sentence you can look at. Left unnamed, the same feeling just turns into the next order. After the close, the useful questions are plain ones. What set me off? What did I tell myself? What will I do the next time it happens? Asked honestly, every day, they do more than any indicator. They won't make the feelings go away, and nobody can promise you that. They put them where you can see them, and that's where the work starts.
Every newcomer is different, but some patterns show up in this job so often that you learn to spot them early.
A common one is the newcomer whose first week goes brilliantly. They decide they've found their thing before the market has had time to agree, and they start trading bigger to match the feeling.
Another is the person who left a good career to do this. They've given something up, so every losing day feels like proof that it was a mistake. They need to hear, more often than they'd admit, that one losing day says nothing about that decision.
Then there's the part-timer, fitting trading around another job and trading tired at the end of a long day. The hours on the screen matter less than the state you're in while you're there, and that's usually the first thing that has to change.
The one who has read every book can be the hardest case. They know what to do and can explain it well, and then they freeze when it's time to press the button. Knowing what to do is the easy part; doing it while the price is moving is the job.
And there's the one who comes straight from school with nothing to unlearn: no habits, no career to miss, no theory about how markets work. Sometimes that's an advantage. Sometimes it means learning everything the hard way, including what a few years in any job would have taught them.
None of these people is doomed, and none of them is a natural. The ones who last tend to be the ones who notice early which pattern is theirs and do something about it.
You'll usually face many difficulties. You make a mistake, lose money and feel stupid. Then you make it again, and feel worse, because this time you knew better.
Sometimes you get lucky and end up making money. This usually happens once or twice, and it will destroy you afterwards. Money you didn't earn teaches you the wrong thing: that breaking your plan works, that you can feel where the market is going, that the rules are for other people. You try it again, and this time the market takes it all back, and more.
In the first few months, everything you thought you knew about the market, and every illusion you came with, will crumble and fall apart. This is the part where most people can't accept the new reality and would rather quit. And many do.
I want to be precise about who I mean. These are newcomers on our own floor, with a mentor and a risk manager around them. People leave because the job turned out to be a job, and the picture they came with didn't survive it. In Elite Is What's Left we wrote about the decisions the firm makes later, when the numbers have had time to speak. This is the part before that, where many people decide for themselves.
I don't think less of anyone who leaves. Finding out early that this isn't for you is a good outcome. The bad outcome is staying for years with the films in your head, paying for the same mistake again and again.
Those who stay carry on figuring out this new world for themselves: its rules, its dos and don'ts, what works for them and what only works in other people's stories. It's slow, and nobody can do it for you. People around you can point things out and stop you, but changing the reaction that got you into the trade is your job alone.
After some time you realise that you're competing against yourself, your impulses and your default reactions. Everyone on the floor trades the same market. What differs is the urge to make back a loss straight away, to add to a trade that's going against you because you're sure it will turn, to grab a quick gain because it feels good, or to trade more after a good day because you feel strong.
This, in my opinion, is the hardest battle, and the ones who win it will ultimately win in life. Someone who can stop when every instinct says keep going, and keep going when every instinct says stop, takes that into everything else they do.
So you can imagine our active community, and the successful traders in our team. They're the ones who won that battle, or are still winning it month after month. This is what I call the Elite.
We trade together. We do other business ventures together. We share our thoughts, we correct each other and we help each other.
You can't buy your way into that. It's built one trader at a time, by the people who stayed. For traders who pass our qualification, Hi2Club is where the community starts, and it opens the moment you pass. You spend the US session with traders who trade US stocks, hear how they prepare before the open and look back after the close, and ask questions while the market is open. There are also market briefings, closed webinars on risk and psychology, and a chat. You can see all of it on the Community page.
Every day we do market research and share it with each other. Now you can be part of it as well.
Register on our website and we'll start sending you a weekly newsletter with our market overview, our analytics and a look back at trades our team has already closed. It's free of charge.
We do this so that you can improve your trading. If it helps your trading even a little, we'll be glad.
To be honest, we do this for ourselves. We give you our research and some of our tools so that you can improve your trading and maybe consider joining us one day. If you do, we gain another great mind in our team.
You don't have to buy anything to receive it, and you don't have to take the qualification to read it. Read it next to your own view of the market, and notice where you disagree. Disagreeing with us for a good reason is the kind of thinking we look for.
Read its terms for three things. After you pass, do you trade a live account with the firm's money, or another simulated one? How much can you lose in a day, and what happens when you do? And how are profit shares decided and paid? If the documents don't answer those plainly, ask the firm before you pay. Ours are on our rules page.
Then ask yourself three more, because no terms page can answer them for you. Can you give this ten hours a day, for most of a year, before you expect anything back? When you lose money by breaking your own rule, will you look for the reason or for an excuse? And if a good day comes early, can you trade the next morning as if it hadn't happened? If the honest answer to any of them is no, you don't need a better firm yet. You need more time, and that's fine. The newsletter costs nothing while you find out.
If you'd rather not read forty pages of terms on your phone, the rating site from the start of this article has a free seven-question check you can run on any firm's rules. It runs in your browser and keeps none of your answers: check your prop firm before you pay.
See the qualification and its prices
Marketing communication. The qualification is taken on a simulated account with live market data. A confirmed pass opens your level, subject to review and identity checks. Not an offer of employment or investment services. Not open to residents of the US, the UK, the Netherlands, Croatia or sanctioned countries. Ranking as shown on TradingIsAJob's rating page, read on 17 November 2026; the score and card quotes are from its hi2morrow card, last checked on 13 November 2026. Prop Firm Pal and Forex Peace Army pages as read on 11 November 2026.
Author: Jamshid Ergashev, CEO of hi2morrow